asiaone
Diva
updated 24 Dec 2010, 17:17
user id password
Tue, Mar 17, 2009
The New Paper
Email Print Decrease text size Increase text size
Fiance used knife to make me sleep with him
by Crystal Chan

HE came home drunk and threatened his Vietnamese fiancee with a knife when she refused to sleep with him.

He did it not just once, but on four occasions.

We are not naming the couple as the Singaporean man had allegedly forced himself on the Vietnamese woman.

His true colours made the 21-year-old woman call off the wedding, which was fixed for solemnisation on Thursday.

On Monday, she fled to First Overseas International Matchmaker, the agency that introduced her to the man, and it arranged for her to return to Ho Chi Minh City the same day.

Mr Francis Toh, the agency owner, told The New Paper on Sunday that his client, 50, a businessman, treated the woman well during their brief courtship after they were introduced last month.

He said: 'We signed the contract and he paid my fee of $6,800. It was agreed that he could take her home after he had obtained a marriage solemnisation date.'

The woman moved into his Serangoon flat late last month, in preparation for her wedding.

True colours

But within two weeks, the man showed his true colours, claimed Mr Toh.

He allegedly came home drunk and demanded to sleep with his fiancee, Lianhe Wanbao reported. When she refused, the man, who was reeking of alcohol, allegedly turned nasty.

She claimed that he threatened her with a knife and said: 'If you don't give in, I'll kill you before killing myself. We'll die together.'

Stuck in a foreign country and facing a knife, she gave in.

It did not help that the man's two older sisters gave her a tough time too.



UNHAPPY ENDING: Matchmaking agency owner Francis Toh (left, with the alleged victim) said the man was introduced by a friend. (Photo: Wanbao)

Mr Toh said: 'My client's sisters are supposedly suffering from depression so when they couldn't control their emotions, they shouted at her for no reason.'

The woman decided to call off the marriage and return to Vietnam after her experience.

After contacting Mr Toh secretly, she sneaked out of the flat and fled to the agency in Katong Shopping Centre.

She told Lianhe Wanbao before she left Singapore: 'My ex-fiance apologised each time he sobered up but he reverted to his devilish side when he became drunk again.

'I came here seeking a better life and I didn't want to live with such a man.'

She said there was no way she could find another Singaporean man as she had lost her virginity.

She said: 'I just hope to get my passport back and return to Vietnam. I plan to learn some skills as I'll have to be independent in future.'

Besides her parents, she has a 25-year-old brother living in Vietnam.

Angered that the marriage was cancelled without any refund of his agency fee, the man refused to hand over her passport.

Mr Toh said: 'I rejected his request for a refund because it was unreasonable. He hid his drinking habit from me when he became my customer. It was also wrong of him to treat his ex-fiancee that way.

'Besides, when both sides signed the contract, it was made clear to them that if the marriage was cancelled because of the man, he would bear the consequences.'

As the man had refused to return the passport, Mr Toh went to the police and got the Vietnamese embassy here to make travel arrangements for her.

He said he trusted the man as he was recommended by a friend.

He said: 'If he came on his own, I'd have been more watchful. But since he was introduced by someone I knew, I thought he was of good character.'

The New Paper on Sunday's attempts to contact the man were unsuccessful.

Other matches gone wrong

14 MAY 2006

Mr Ang Hock Chye, 37, a clerk, returns to his Mei Ling Street home to find his Vietnamese wife had left. She took her passport, clothes and jewellery.

Her friend and compatriot also left her Singaporean husband on the same day.

6 APR 2005

A report in The New Paper quotes Mr Mark Lin, owner of Vietnam Brides International, as saying that for every hundred marriages involving Vietnamese women and local men, at least three brides initiate break-ups.

He cited the language barrier and cultural differences as the main reasons.

This article was first published in The New Paper.





readers' comments


The anti-vice wouldn't know because this agency operate a decent business in the day.In the nite is where the action begin inside the toilet.Cleaners often found used condoms on the toilet floor.
This agency business is so bad if the boss don't think of a way to make money how to pay his rental.2 years ago I still see wedding buffet held in the agency ,last year i think hadly got any marriage transaction because no wedding buffet at all.
The agency look more like "Thailand goldfish bowl"all the vietnam girls roughly about 10 of them sitting in the agency.I was told that the boss ask them to put with heavy makeup and wearing little and revealing clothes to attract men to take them out.Every day the girls made so much of noise laughing and playing with the boss surrounding neighbours hated them so .....
Posted by electric127 on Thu, 19 Mar 2009 at 13:33 PM
Though we can't say that who's virgin and who's not. But the way the boss operate it, it's no better than opening a high class prostitution which don't get nab by the anti vice.
Posted by comp_craze on Wed, 18 Mar 2009 at 19:51 PM


I think you are refering to the same agency i known of.Lately alot of publicity from reporter giving free advertisement to this agency.How do you know these vietnamese girl are virgin? Bear in mind these girls can be taken out for testing for 1 or 2 weeks just pay the agency and they don't care what you do to the girls.(Remember the cobbler case)
These vietnam girls come on social visit pass and allow to stay for 2 or 3 months.Some of them cannot married off and got to go home than they come back again.These are the one that have no choice but to look into other sources to earn money that they have spent on their passage here besides looking for a husband.In the building that this agency situated had a lot of Japanese lounge,sources said that these girls are servicing all the .....
Posted by electric127 on Wed, 18 Mar 2009 at 13:59 PM


I think you are refering to the same agency i known of.Lately alot of publicity from reporter giving free advertisement to this agency.How do you know these vietnamese girl are virgin? Bear in mind these girls can be taken out for testing for 1 or 2 weeks just pay the agency and they don't care what you do to the girls.(Remember the cobbler case)
These vietnam girls come on social visit pass and allow to stay for 2 or 3 months.Some of them cannot married off and got to go home than they come back again.These are the one that have no choice but to look into other sources to earn money that they have spent on their passage here besides looking for a husband.In the building that this agency situated had a lot of Japanese lounge,sources said that these girls are servicing all the .....
Posted by electric127 on Wed, 18 Mar 2009 at 13:52 PM
Bosses with a heart would give 1000 - 2000 USD.
But for this boss, sad to say, he only give 300sing.
And in this case, he only give 50 to the girl as transport. He got a BIG FAT deal.
Posted by comp_craze on Tue, 17 Mar 2009 at 15:15 PM
MOST Vietnamese are good looking, slim and very proportionately built. They are well sought after by Koreans, Taiwanese, Malaysians and our fellow Singaporeans. They are mostly obedient because of their upbringing. Their biggest set back is shyness and lack knowledge of the outside world. Owing to this, there had been many reports of attempted suicides because they could not overcome the cultural differences in their new homes. Many ran away for the same reason. The Vietnamese government has already ruled such marriage agencies illegal and is banned from setting up offices in Vietnam. However, this trade is still going on. Understand the poor parents of the girls get only a small portion of the fees charged (one to two thousand US dollars) and the agencies get a lion share of the payment. This is the saddest part of the deal.
Posted by DuLichDat on Tue, 17 Mar 2009 at 15:02 PM
I know the boss of this matchmaking agency. He has been frying news about all this Vietnam Bride stuff every now and then.
The purpose of him doing this is to make FREE Advertisement as he don't want to spend more money in it.
He treated his Vietnam bride as prostitute or making money tools as they're eating only maggie mees in the agency, and don't pay alot to the families when they married off or had bad incident like this even though he make between $5000 - $6000 for each gal he married off.
We should boycott such an agency when there's no human right and it's as if like an high class prostitute. Except that you get all virgin gal when you don't get them in geylang.
Posted by comp_craze on Tue, 17 Mar 2009 at 13:39 PM
Don't use one stone to kill all birds.
Posted by skywed on Tue, 17 Mar 2009 at 13:23 PM
Don’t try to downplay singaporean men by publishing in Diva about the unfortunate incidents Singaporean men are going thru, what you had reported are cases which can happens also to any singy women. I have couples of friends who went thru happy marriages to Vietnamese and Thais, given birth to many “good genes’ kids. And most of them don’t go thru marriage agency but personally flew up North to have their own picks, as most are of tertiary education. I can only say that they are happily married and recommending the rest of the pretty and nice personalities village women to the rest of friends who are still single.
Posted by antisillypor on Tue, 17 Mar 2009 at 09:42 AM

asiaone
Copyright © 2010 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved.